GRWG UV Sub-Group Web Meeting 2014-12-16

Hyperspectral SNO comparisons of VIS channels

  1. Rose Munro (Chair UV Sub-Group) - Introduction
  2. Xu Na (CMA) – Retrieving the SRF of VIS channels using hyperspectral instruments
  3. Dave Doelling (NASA) – Introduction of the SCIAMACHY SBAF web tool
  4. Dave Doelling (NASA) – Inter-calibration of both GEO (Met-9) and LEO (MODIS) against SCIAMACHY
  5. Yves Goevarts (Rayference) - Hyperspectral characterisation of Libya-4 site using GOME2 data and RTMs
  6. Ruediger Lang (EUMETSAT) – GOME2 as hyperspectral reference for MSG & AVHRR
  7. All - Discussion


Guest Chair: Rose Munro

CMA: Xu Na, Lin Chen

CNES: Bertrand Fougnie

DLR: Thomas Walzel

EUMETSAT: Rose Munro, Marcel Dobber, Ruediger Lang, Tim Hewison, Sebastien Wagner, Rob Roebeling, Viju John

ESA: Berit Ahlers

JMA: Masaya Takahashi, Arata Okuyama, Ryoku Yoshino, Keita Hosaka

NASA: Dave Doelling, Amit Angal, Ben Scarino, David Flittner

NOAA: Fangfang Yu,

NPL: Nigel Fox, Emma Woolliams, Javier Gorrono and Tracy Scanlon

Rayference: Yves Govaerts

SRON: Ralph Snel

Other: Oksana Kushnyr


Xu Na presented her variational method of retrieving the SRF of IR channels in absorbing spectral bands (e.g. water vapour) using comparisons with hyperspectral sounders.
Applicability to VIS/NIR? - Yes, but limited to spectral errors, rather than radiometric. The technique will also only work well for channels in absorbing bands - not for window channels.
Uncertainty in retrieved SRF? - Yes it is possible, but Xu has not looked at it yet - although she hopes to do so by the next GRWG meeting.

Dave presented NASA's new online tool for calculating the Spectral Band Adjustment Factor, which is based on SCIAMACHY observations over different surfaces. He also showed how limitng the range of conditions (e.g. Water Vapour column amount) can improve the uncertainty on the SBAFs. In response to questions, Dave confirmed this tool will include GOES-R and provide uncertainties and that it uses the same SRFs as used in GSICS. Sebastien asked whether the SCIAMACHY lunar observations could be used by this tool. Ralph Snel hopes to look at this.Ruediger pointed out the problem with analysing GOME-2 lunar observations, which would require a full

Dave also provided a refresher on the work his group has performed using hyperspectral sensors as a reference for the inter-calibration of GEO imagers. In this case, the calibration of SCIAMACHY was first checked to MODIS using polar SNOs and found to be <0.2%/decade. This was then compared with the VIS0.6 channel of Meteosat-9/SEVIRI, based on approximately 40 ray-matched observations per month, which have a standard error ~4-5%. He showed this method gave comparable results to other inter-calibration methods (e.g. DCC).

Yves Govaerts described comparisons of RTM simulations of TOA radiances spectra over the Libya-4 site with MODIS, MERIS and GOME-2. Yves concluded that he considered LibRadTran V2.0b to be the most accurate model for this application. He believes the models are sufficiently independent of the BRDF model if the solar zenith angle is limited to 30°.

Rüdiger Lang provided an overview of inter-comparisons that have been conducted at EUMETSAT using GOME-2 as a hyperspectral reference instrument. This has been applied to the visible channels of Meteosat/SEVIRI and Metop/AVHRR. He also addressed the potential impact of these results to aerosol retrievals, for which inter-calibration will need to be peformed routinely and automatically. Rüdiger pointed out the impact of the differential degradation of the short-wave GOME-2 channels. A model has been developed to correct for this change (up to 3%). When this correction is applied to the AVHRR comparisons, the results suggest the AVHRR calbration is stable, with a constant bias. His initial comparisons with the geostationary Meteosat/SEVIRI are limited to the sub-satellite point, which still includes a 15% scatter, but shows a clear dark bias of ~8%, which show some variations with time, which need further investigation.
Topic attachments
I Attachment Action Size DateSorted ascending Who Comment
GSICSweb_SBAF_doelling_2014_12final.pptxpptx GSICSweb_SBAF_doelling_2014_12final.pptx manage 1 MB 16 Dec 2014 - 07:51 TimHewison GSICSweb_SBAF_doelling_2014_12final.pptx
GSICSweb_SCIAcal_doelling_2014_12final.pptxpptx GSICSweb_SCIAcal_doelling_2014_12final.pptx manage 1 MB 16 Dec 2014 - 07:51 TimHewison GSICSweb_SCIAcal_doelling_2014_12final.pptx
201416_Govaerts_GSICS.pdfpdf 201416_Govaerts_GSICS.pdf manage 1 MB 16 Dec 2014 - 12:30 TimHewison  
GSICS_UVSubgroup_GOME-2vsAVHRRandSeviri_RLang.pptxpptx GSICS_UVSubgroup_GOME-2vsAVHRRandSeviri_RLang.pptx manage 3 MB 16 Dec 2014 - 12:33 TimHewison  
20141216-GSICSwebmeeting.pptppt 20141216-GSICSwebmeeting.ppt manage 1 MB 16 Dec 2014 - 13:06 TimHewison  
Topic revision: r5 - 16 Dec 2014, TimHewison
This site is powered by FoswikiCopyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding GSICS Wiki? Send feedback